Is Bullymake Worth the Price? A Brutally Honest Review
This post contains affiliate links, which means we may receive commission if you click on links to products or services and make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you. Thankyou!
If you’ve ever bought a “durable” dog toy only to find it shredded within minutes, you already understand the problem Bullymake is trying to solve.
This isn’t your typical cute dog subscription box filled with plush toys and novelty treats. Bullymake is built for a very specific type of customer:
👉 Dogs that destroy everything
So the real question isn’t just “Is Bullymake good?”
It’s:
👉 It’s worth buying every month?
This in-depth review will discuss every aspect of Bullymake, from the types of boxes to materials, durability, cost-effectiveness, etc.
Brand Overview & Positioning
The Bullymake brand has managed to differentiate itself from other dog brands in a unique way, catering to extreme chewers.
Whereas other subscription box brands such as BarkBox aim at entertaining the customers, Bullymake’s primary objective is:
“To create dog toys that can withstand the attention span of dogs.”
This may seem quite easy to accomplish but, in reality, it defines the very purpose of the brand.
🔍 What Makes Bullymake Unique?
- Durability trumps cuteness
- Uses industrial-quality materials
- Designed for pit bulls, German shepherds, labs, and other extreme chewers
- Provides customization based on chew levels
👉 Not a casual pet owner’s choice; for those who want to vent their frustrations
✓ Pros
- Built specifically for aggressive chewers
- Strong customization options
- High durability materials
- Replacement guarantee reduces risk
- Convenient recurring delivery
- Better long-term value for destructive dogs
X Cons
- Monthly subscription cost adds up
- Not ideal for small or gentle dogs
- Some toys lack “fun factor”
- Hard toys may not appeal to all dogs
- Cancellation policies require attention
📦 What Comes in a Bullymake Box?
A typical Bullymake box includes:
🦴 Standard Box Contents:
- 2–3 ultra-durable toys
- 3 treat bags
- Monthly themed packaging
🎁 Key Detail:
The value isn’t just in quantity—it’s in material quality and longevity.
📦 Bullymake Box Types & Variations
This is where Bullymake stands out compared to almost every competitor.
🦴 Standard Box (Toys + Treats)
Includes:
- 2–3 durable toys
- 3 bags of treats
Best For:
- Dogs that enjoy both chewing and food rewards
- Owners who want a balanced experience
👉 This is the default subscription most users choosea
💪 Toys-Only Box (Most Practical for Power Chewers)
Includes:
- 4–5 heavy-duty toys
- No treats
Why it matters:
- Perfect for dogs with allergies
- Maximizes durability value
- Eliminates unnecessary extras
👉 For aggressive chewers, this is often the best-value option
🧵 Material-Specific Custom Boxes
This is where Bullymake becomes highly strategic.
You can choose toy types based on your dog’s behavior:
🔹 Nylon (Extreme Chewers)
- Hard, bone-like material
- Longest-lasting
- Not ideal for dogs who prefer soft textures
🔹 Rubber (Balanced Play)
- Durable but flexible
- Great for chewing + fetch
🔹 Rope (Tug Lovers)
- Strong fibers
- Best for interactive play
🔹 Ballistic Fabric (Heavy Pullers)
- Reinforced cloth material
- Tougher than plush
🔹 Plush (Light Chewers Only)
- Softer toys
- Not recommended for aggressive chewers
👉 This level of customization is something most subscription boxes simply don’t offer.
Materials & Durability Analysis
Bullymake’s biggest claim is durability—so let’s analyze that properly.
Materials Used:
Industrial Nylon
- Extremely hard
- Designed to withstand prolonged chewing
- Can last weeks or months
Natural Rubber
- Slightly softer
- More engaging for dogs
- Good balance of durability + playability
Ballistic Fabric
- Reinforced layers
- Designed for tearing resistance
Real-World Durability Insight
- Most toys last significantly longer than standard pet store toys
- However:
👉 No toy is truly indestructible
👉 Very aggressive dogs can still damage them over time
🔄 Replacement Guarantee
One of Bullymake’s strongest value drivers:
If your dog destroys a toy, they’ll replace it
This changes the value equation completely.
Instead of:
- Buying new toys repeatedly
You get:
- A risk-reduced subscription model
This is a major reason many users stick with Bullymake long-term.
💸 Pricing Breakdown
💰 Subscription Costs:
- Monthly: Higher cost
- 3–6 months: Moderate savings
- 12 months: Best value
Typical range:
👉 $29 – $45/month
Real Cost Comparison
Let’s break it down realistically:
Without Bullymake:
- 3 durable toys/month = $45–$75
- Frequent replacements
With Bullymake:
- ~$30–$45/month
- More durable toys
- Replacement guarantee
If your dog destroys toys regularly, Bullymake can actually save money over time
Real User Experience
Positive Patterns:
- Dogs stay engaged longer
- Toys last longer than expected
- Owners feel less frustration
Negative Patterns:
- Some dogs find toys “too hard”
- Not all dogs enjoy the textures
- Subscription commitment concerns
👉 Important insight:
Durability ≠ entertainment for every dog
Who Bullymake Is REALLY For?
Best for:
- Pitbulls, Labradors, German Shepherds
- Tough toys that will be torn apart in just a couple of hours
- Pet owners who get tired of constantly buying new toys
Not advised for:
- Small breeds of dogs
- Non-chewer dogs
- Dogs that love cuddly toys
What about the others?
| Features | Bullymake | Other Dog Subscriptions |
|---|---|---|
| Made in the USA* | ✔ | ✖ |
| Non-toxic, Phthalate-free, FDA Approved Materials | ✔ | ✖ |
| Complete Box Customization* | ✔ | ✖ |
| 5 Items per Monthly Box | ✔ | ✖ |
| 100% Durability Guarantee | ✔ | ✔ |
| Scented & Treat Dispensing Chews for Increased Satisfaction | ✔ | ✔ |
| Shipped in a Box for Added Unboxing Fun! | ✔ | ✖ |
❓ FAQs:
Variety & fun → BarkBox wins
Final Verdict
Bullymake is not trying to be everything.
It is designed to solve one very specific problem:
👉 Dogs destroying toys too fast
And in that specific job—it performs very well.
The Honest Reality
Bullymake works best when:
- Your dog is highly destructive
- You value durability over aesthetics
- You want a consistent toy solution
It struggles when:
- Your dog prefers soft toys
- You want variety over strength
- You don’t need monthly deliveries
Bottom Line
Here’s the real truth:
Bullymake is not a “fun subscription box” It’s a problem-solving system for destructive dogs
Final Decision Logic
- If your dog destroys toys weekly → Worth it
- If toys already last months → Overkill
Bullymake is expensive—until you compare it to how much you’re already wasting on destroyed toys.